Best Practices for Archiving Emails: 7 Tools Compared 2026
By ToolNimba Editorial Team November 20, 2026 8 min read
We did not test these tools hands-on. Picks are based on vendor documentation and public information. Read our editorial policy and disclosure.
- Top pick
MimecastUnified email security and data governance
Starting priceSee websiteCheck out MimecastRead our review - Runner-up
Proofpoint Email ProtectionStopping phishing and evasive attacks
Starting priceSee websiteCheck out Proofpoint Email ProtectionRead our review - Also great
Microsoft Exchange OnlineHosted business email with retention controls
Starting price$5.40 per user per monthCheck out Microsoft Exchange OnlineRead our review
How we researched this
We compared official pricing and feature pages, app store listings, privacy policies and public user reviews. Prices change, so check the provider's site before you pay.
Direct answer
Mimecast is a strong first pick for teams that want email security and archiving in one platform, while Smarsh Enterprise Archive and Global Relay Archive suit organizations with strict compliance and supervision needs. This guide compares seven email archiving and protection options to help you pick the right fit.
Key takeaways
- Mimecast combines email security, data protection and governance on one platform, which suits teams that want archiving tied to threat protection.
- Proofpoint Email Protection focuses on stopping phishing and evasive attacks and is best paired with a dedicated archive for retention.
- Microsoft Exchange Online provides hosted business email with retention and compliance controls for organizations already in the Microsoft ecosystem.
- Smarsh Enterprise Archive and Global Relay Archive are purpose-built for compliance capture, supervision and eDiscovery across many channels.
Quick comparison
| Name | Best for | Starting price | Free plan | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unified email security and data governance | See website | See website | Visit | |
| Stopping phishing and evasive attacks | See website | See website | Visit | |
| Hosted business email with retention controls | $5.40 per user per month | Free trial | Visit | |
| Collaboration suite with built-in retention | See website | See website | Visit | |
| Compliance capture across many channels | See website | See website | Visit | |
| Compliant archiving and eDiscovery | See website | See website | Visit | |
| Enterprise data security and management | See website | See website | Visit |
Email Archiving Best Practices, one by one
Choosing the right archiving setup starts with clear retention rules, access controls and searchable records. ToolNimba compared documented features and vendor pages across seven options to help you match a tool to your archiving goals.
Mimecast presents itself as one platform covering email and collaboration security, data protection, AI security, behavior management and data governance. For archiving projects, that means retention and governance can sit alongside inbound threat protection rather than in a separate silo. It fits organizations that want a consolidated approach to protecting and retaining email while keeping security and compliance functions under one vendor relationship.
Because the platform spans several solutions, teams with only basic retention needs may find it broader than required. Confirm which capabilities are included in the specific solution you evaluate. If your priority is a standalone compliance archive with supervision workflows, a dedicated archive vendor may be a better match.
- Combines email security with data protection
- Includes data governance and behavior management
- Single platform across several solutions
- Broad platform may exceed simple archiving needs
- Feature depth varies by solution

Proofpoint Email Protection
Best for: Stopping phishing and evasive attacks
Proofpoint Email Protection is positioned around AI email security, using behavioral AI to stop phishing, business email compromise and evasive attacks that bypass the built-in defenses of common cloud email platforms. It can be deployed through an API or a secure email gateway. It fits organizations that want a stronger security layer in front of their existing email service while archiving is handled elsewhere.
The product page emphasizes protection rather than long-term retention, so it is not a substitute for a dedicated archive. Teams that need supervision, legal hold or eDiscovery should pair it with an archiving platform. Confirm integration details with your email provider before planning a deployment.
- Behavioral AI for threat detection
- Deploys via API or secure email gateway
- Targets attacks that bypass built-in defenses
- Archiving is not its stated focus
- Needs pairing with a retention system

Microsoft Exchange Online
Best for: Hosted business email with retention controls
Microsoft Exchange Online is Microsoft's business email service, available as a hosted offering or for your own servers. It provides the mailbox foundation many organizations already use, with retention and compliance controls that can support archiving practices. It fits teams standardized on Microsoft tools that want email retention managed close to where mail is stored and administered.
Retention and archiving depth depend on how the service is configured and which capabilities are enabled. Organizations with strict supervision or multi-channel capture requirements may need a dedicated archive alongside it. Check the specific retention features available to your setup before relying on it as a complete archive.
- Hosted service or own servers
- Built into Microsoft productivity tools
- Retention and compliance features available
- Archiving depth depends on configuration
- Best value inside the Microsoft ecosystem
Google Workspace is a suite of secure online productivity and collaboration tools aimed at teams of all sizes. For email archiving, it keeps mail inside the same environment where documents and communication happen, which simplifies administration for organizations already working in Google's ecosystem. It fits teams that want retention handled within their everyday productivity platform.
Archiving behavior depends on the retention settings enabled for your organization, and supervision or legal workflows may call for a specialized archive. Teams with heavy regulatory capture needs should compare dedicated archive vendors. Verify which retention controls apply to your edition before finalizing a policy.
- Secure online productivity tools
- Suits teams of all sizes
- Retention controls within the suite
- Archiving features tied to suite settings
- Third-party archive may be needed for supervision

Smarsh Enterprise Archive
Best for: Compliance capture across many channels
Smarsh Enterprise Archive is part of a platform for digital communications governance and archiving, with cloud-based capture, archiving and supervision across many channels. It is designed for organizations that must manage the risk in electronic communications and keep searchable records for review. It fits regulated industries where supervision and retention policies are central to daily operations.
The platform is oriented toward compliance-heavy environments, so smaller teams with simple retention needs may find it more than necessary. Evaluate whether your required channels and workflows match its capture scope. If you only need basic mailbox retention, a suite-native option may be simpler.
- Cloud-based capture and archiving
- Supervision across many channels
- Built around communications risk
- Focused on regulated environments
- May be more than small teams need
Global Relay Archive is presented as a provider of compliant electronic communications archiving, messaging, supervision and eDiscovery. It suits organizations that need to retain communications in a defensible way and search them for legal or regulatory purposes. Teams in finance and other regulated sectors often look for this combination of archiving and supervision in a single platform.
Because it is built around compliance workflows, planning retention rules and reviewer access takes deliberate effort up front. Organizations without regulatory obligations may prefer a lighter retention tool. Confirm that the channels and message types you must capture are supported before committing.
- Archiving, messaging and supervision
- EDiscovery support
- Compliance-focused design
- Aimed at regulated organizations
- Setup requires policy planning

Veritas Enterprise Vault
Best for: Enterprise data security and management
Veritas Enterprise Vault sits within a portfolio now presented alongside Cohesity, focused on AI-powered data security and management. The offering emphasizes immutable backup, AI-based early threat detection and rapid data recovery. For archiving strategy, it fits enterprises that want email retention considered as part of a wider data protection and recovery plan rather than an isolated mailbox function.
The messaging centers on data security and management broadly, so email-specific archiving details should be confirmed directly. Organizations seeking a narrow, email-only archive may find the scope larger than needed. Map your retention requirements to the platform's data management capabilities before deciding.
- Immutable backup against ransomware
- AI-based early threat detection
- Rapid data recovery capabilities
- Broad data platform, not email-only
- Requires planning across data sources
How the list was put together
ToolNimba compared documented features, vendor pages and stated limits for each tool in this guide. Descriptions rely on vendor homepage excerpts and widely known product facts, and no hands-on testing was performed. Details such as retention options, deployment models and supported channels can change, so confirm specifics on each vendor site before buying. The ordering reflects editorial judgment about how well each option matches common email archiving practices.
What to confirm before you sign up
- Check how long messages are retained and whether retention rules are configurable.
- Confirm which channels and message types the archive can capture.
- Ask how search, legal hold and eDiscovery exports work for reviewers.
- Verify deployment options such as cloud, on-premises or hybrid.
- Review access controls, audit trails and encryption for stored mail.
Sources
Official websites of the products reviewed above. Features and prices were checked against these sites when the guide was written, and they can change, so confirm on the vendor site before you buy.
Frequently asked questions
What is the first step in archiving emails properly?
Start by defining a retention policy that states which messages must be kept, for how long and who can access them. Then choose a tool whose capture and search features match those rules. Documenting the policy first makes tool comparison much easier.
Should email security and archiving be handled by one vendor?
It can simplify administration when protection and retention sit on one platform, as with Mimecast. However, some teams prefer a dedicated archive paired with a separate security layer such as Proofpoint Email Protection. The right choice depends on how much consolidation your team can manage.
When do I need a dedicated compliance archive?
If your organization must supervise communications, respond to legal requests or meet strict recordkeeping rules, a dedicated archive such as Smarsh Enterprise Archive or Global Relay Archive is usually the better fit. Suite-native retention in Microsoft or Google environments can cover simpler needs.
How should archived email be protected from loss?
Look for immutable storage, encryption and clear backup and recovery processes. Veritas Enterprise Vault, for example, emphasizes immutable backup and rapid recovery within a broader data security platform. Test recovery procedures so you know archived mail can be restored when needed.

