Best Simulated Phishing Software: 7 Tools Compared for 2026
By ToolNimba Editorial Team November 20, 2026 7 min read
We did not test these tools hands-on. Picks are based on vendor documentation and public information. Read our editorial policy and disclosure.
- Top pick
KnowBe4Broad human risk reduction platform
Starting price$5.30 per seat per monthCheck out KnowBe4Read our review - Runner-up
Proofpoint Security Awareness TrainingRisk-based automated training programs
Starting priceSee websiteCheck out Proofpoint Security Awareness TrainingRead our review - Also great
Cofense Phishing Defense CenterPhishing that bypasses filters
Starting priceSee websiteCheck out Cofense Phishing Defense CenterRead our review
How we researched this
We compared official pricing and feature pages, app store listings, privacy policies and public user reviews. Prices change, so check the provider's site before you pay.
Direct answer
KnowBe4 is the first pick for most teams because it bundles simulated phishing with broad security awareness training in one platform. Proofpoint suits risk-based, automated programs, while PhishingBox fits focused simulation and training needs. Seven options are compared here.
Key takeaways
- KnowBe4 combines simulated phishing with a broad security awareness training platform for reducing human risk.
- Proofpoint ZenGuide turns real phishing attacks into personalized training that targets risk.
- Cofense pairs AI detection with human insight and real-time training to counter phishing that bypasses filters.
- Hoxhunt automates adaptive phishing training and email incident response to reduce employee cyber risk.
Quick comparison
| Name | Best for | Starting price | Free plan | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Broad human risk reduction platform | $5.30 per seat per month | See website | Visit | |
| Risk-based automated training programs | See website | See website | Visit | |
| Phishing that bypasses filters | See website | See website | Visit | |
| Teams already using Mimecast | See website | See website | Visit | |
| Organizations using Barracuda security | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| Adaptive automated phishing training | See website | See website | Visit | |
| Focused phishing simulation and training | $825.00 per year | Free trial | Visit |
Simulated Phishing Software Compared, one by one
Simulated phishing software lets organizations test employees with realistic fake attacks and follow up with training. ToolNimba compared documented features and vendor pages across seven platforms to help you shortlist the right fit.
KnowBe4 is a security platform built around reducing human risk, combining security awareness training, simulated phishing, email security and agent security in one place. It fits organizations that want a single vendor to run phishing simulations alongside ongoing awareness education and broader defenses. Teams looking for a comprehensive program rather than a standalone simulation tool are the natural audience.
Because KnowBe4 spans several security areas, smaller teams may find parts of the platform beyond their immediate needs, and getting the full setup running takes planning. If you only want basic phishing simulations, a narrower tool may be simpler. Choose KnowBe4 when you want awareness training and phishing testing under one roof.
- Combines simulated phishing with security awareness training
- Also covers email and agent security
- Single platform for multiple human risk needs
- Large platform may be more than small teams need
- Full feature set requires setup effort

Proofpoint Security Awareness Training
Best for: Risk-based automated training programs
Proofpoint Security Awareness Training, built around ZenGuide, automates risk-based security awareness training and converts real phishing attacks into personalized education aimed at changing behavior. It suits organizations that want training driven by actual risk signals rather than generic campaigns. Security teams already thinking about employee behavior as a measurable risk will find the approach aligned with that goal.
The emphasis is on awareness training and behavior change, so teams wanting a single tool for simulation plus email gateway security may need to look elsewhere or combine products. Results depend on the quality of the risk data feeding the automation. Pick Proofpoint when personalized, risk-driven training is the priority.
- Automates risk-based awareness training
- Turns real phishing attacks into personalized lessons
- Focuses on changing behavior over time
- Centered on training rather than full email security
- Personalization depends on accurate risk data

Cofense Phishing Defense Center
Best for: Phishing that bypasses filters
Cofense Phishing Defense Center focuses on stopping phishing attacks that bypass traditional filters, combining AI detection, real-time training and expert response across channels. It fits security teams that want simulation and reporting tied directly to real threats, and that value human analysis alongside automation. Organizations facing sophisticated phishing will find the defense-first framing useful.
Cofense leans toward phishing defense and response rather than being a standalone simulation and training suite, so teams wanting a simple campaign tool may find it broader than needed. It can also overlap with existing email security investments. Choose Cofense when real-world phishing defense and rapid response matter most.
- Combines AI detection with human insight
- Real-time training tied to threats
- Expert response across channels
- Defense-oriented rather than pure simulation
- May overlap with existing email security

Mimecast Awareness Training
Best for: Teams already using Mimecast
Mimecast Awareness Training sits within a platform covering email and collaboration security, data protection, AI security, behavior management and data governance. It suits organizations that want awareness training as part of a wider security stack rather than a separate point tool. Teams already standardizing on Mimecast for email security are the most natural fit.
Because training is one component of a larger platform, the full value depends on adopting more of the suite, and standalone simulation buyers may prefer a dedicated tool. Evaluating it in isolation can be harder than judging a focused product. Pick Mimecast when you want awareness training integrated with broader email and data security.
- Awareness training within a broader security platform
- Covers email and collaboration security
- Adds behavior management and data governance
- Training is one part of a larger suite
- Value depends on adopting the wider platform

Barracuda Security Awareness Training
Best for: Organizations using Barracuda security
Barracuda Security Awareness Training is offered within a portfolio spanning email protection, application protection, network security and data protection. It fits organizations that prefer to consolidate security vendors and want awareness training alongside other defenses. Teams already using Barracuda products can keep training close to their existing security operations.
Training is one part of a wide portfolio rather than the core focus, so buyers wanting deep, dedicated simulation features may find specialized tools a better match. The value is strongest when combined with other Barracuda products. Choose it when vendor consolidation and integrated security are priorities.
- Awareness training within a broad security portfolio
- Covers email, application, network and data protection
- Fits consolidated vendor strategies
- Training is one piece of a wide portfolio
- Less specialized than dedicated simulation tools
Hoxhunt is a human risk management platform that automates adaptive phishing training, security awareness training and email incident response to measurably reduce employee cyber risk across the enterprise. It suits larger organizations that want simulations to adapt to each employee over time. Teams focused on measurable behavior change rather than one-off campaigns will find the approach relevant.
The enterprise orientation means smaller teams may find it more than they need, and adaptive automation takes time to tune to your workforce. Organizations wanting simple, manual campaign tools may prefer a lighter option. Pick Hoxhunt when adaptive, automated training and incident response are central goals.
- Automates adaptive phishing training
- Includes email incident response
- Aims at measurable risk reduction
- Enterprise focus may suit larger teams best
- Adaptive automation needs time to tune
PhishingBox provides phishing attack simulations and awareness training designed to defend employees against phishing, smishing, vishing, spear phishing and other social engineering attacks. It fits teams that want a focused simulation and training tool without a broader security platform attached. Organizations running regular campaigns across multiple channels are the core audience.
The scope is deliberately narrower than full security platforms, so teams wanting email security or incident response in the same product will need to look elsewhere. It is best treated as a dedicated simulation and training tool. Choose PhishingBox when targeted, multi-channel phishing testing is the main requirement.
- Simulations across email, smishing and vishing
- Includes awareness training
- Covers spear phishing and social engineering
- Narrower scope than full security platforms
- Fewer adjacent security features
How the list was put together
ToolNimba compared documented features, vendor homepage descriptions and stated limits for each platform, focusing on how simulated phishing and awareness training are described. We did not run hands-on tests, and details can change, so confirm current capabilities on each vendor site before buying. The ordering reflects editorial judgment about fit for common simulated phishing needs, not a scored ranking.
What to confirm before you sign up
- Check which simulation channels are supported, such as email, smishing and vishing
- Confirm how training content is delivered and whether it adapts to employee behavior
- Ask how reporting tracks behavior change over time
- Verify integration with your existing email and identity systems
- Review support and onboarding options for your team size
Sources
Official websites of the products reviewed above. Features and prices were checked against these sites when the guide was written, and they can change, so confirm on the vendor site before you buy.
Frequently asked questions
What should simulated phishing software include?
Look for realistic campaign templates, reporting on who clicked or reported, and follow-up training tied to results. Multi-channel coverage and integration with your email stack are useful additions. Match the feature depth to your program maturity.
How do I choose between a dedicated tool and a platform?
Dedicated tools such as PhishingBox focus on simulation and training, which suits teams wanting a simple program. Platforms like KnowBe4 or Mimecast bundle training with broader security, which suits organizations consolidating vendors. Decide based on scope and existing investments.
Can simulated phishing training adapt to each employee?
Some platforms, including Hoxhunt and Proofpoint, describe adaptive or risk-based training that responds to individual behavior and real threats. This can target training where risk is highest. Confirm how adaptation works during a vendor demo.
How often should phishing simulations run?
Many teams run simulations on a recurring schedule and adjust frequency based on results and risk. The right cadence depends on your workforce and program goals. Ask vendors how scheduling and automation are handled before deciding.

