ToolNimba
⭐ Comparisons

ChurchTrac Alternatives: 6 Church Software Picks for 2026

By ToolNimba Editorial Team November 20, 2026 6 min read

We did not test these tools hands-on. Picks are based on vendor documentation and public information. Read our editorial policy and disclosure.

ChurchTrac Alternatives
  1. Top pick
    Planning Center logoPlanning Center

    Broad ministry and service planning

    Starting price$5 per month
    Check out Planning CenterRead our review
  2. Runner-up
    Breeze ChMS logoBreeze ChMS

    Simple, easy church management

    Starting price$72 per month
    Check out Breeze ChMSRead our review
  3. Also great
    Tithe.ly logoTithe.ly

    Giving plus church management

    Starting price$19 per month
    Check out Tithe.lyRead our review

How we researched this

We compared official pricing and feature pages, app store listings, privacy policies and public user reviews. Prices change, so check the provider's site before you pay.

Direct answer

Planning Center is the first pick for most churches weighing ChurchTrac alternatives, thanks to its broad ministry and service planning coverage. Breeze ChMS suits teams that want simplicity, while Tithe.ly fits churches prioritizing giving and engagement. Six options are compared here.

Key takeaways

  • Planning Center covers service planning, events, communication and congregation connection in one suite.
  • Breeze ChMS emphasizes ease of use for organizing data, events, giving and attendance.
  • Tithe.ly combines online giving, church management and engagement tools for churches of every size.
  • Rock RMS centers on relationships and offers an open platform with active community support.

Quick comparison

NameBest forStarting priceFree plan
Planning CenterBroad ministry and service planning$5 per monthYesVisit
Breeze ChMSSimple, easy church management$72 per monthFree trialVisit
Tithe.lyGiving plus church management$19 per monthYesVisit
PushpayEngagement, giving and streamingSee websiteFree trialVisit
Rock RMSRelationship-centered, extensible management$4.45 per average weekend attendeeSee websiteVisit
ShelbyNextMembership and financial toolsSee websiteSee websiteVisit

ChurchTrac alternatives compared, one by one

Churches outgrow a management tool for many reasons, from giving needs to volunteer coordination. ToolNimba compared documented features and stated limits across six ChurchTrac alternatives to help you shortlist.

01Planning Center logo

Planning Center

Best for: Broad ministry and service planning

Check out Planning Center
Starting price$5 per month
Free planYes

Planning Center is a church management platform built around organizing ministries, coordinating events, planning services and communicating with teams. It also aims to connect the congregation with the wider church. Churches that run multiple ministries and want service planning and team coordination under one roof are the natural fit, especially where volunteers and staff work across several areas at once.

Because it spans many functions, the platform can feel extensive for a small church with simple needs, and teams may need time to adopt each area. If you mainly want basic member records and giving, a lighter tool such as Breeze ChMS may be easier to start with.

What we like
  • Covers events, services and communication
  • Connects the congregation with ministry teams
  • Integrated church management approach
Watch out for
  • Many modules to learn
  • May be more than small churches need
02Breeze ChMS logo

Breeze ChMS

Best for: Simple, easy church management

Check out Breeze ChMS
Starting price$72 per month
Free planFree trial

Breeze ChMS presents itself as an easy-to-use church management system for organizing data, managing events, offering online giving and tracking attendance. It suits smaller churches or volunteer-led teams that want straightforward tools without a long setup. The focus on simplicity makes it a common starting point for congregations moving off spreadsheets or basic records.

Simplicity comes with limits: churches with complex multi-ministry scheduling or deep reporting needs may find it less capable than broader suites. If service planning across many teams is central to your work, Planning Center or Rock RMS may be a better match.

What we like
  • Positioned as easy to use
  • Handles data, events and attendance
  • Includes online giving
Watch out for
  • Less depth for complex ministries
  • Fewer advanced planning features
03Tithe.ly logo

Tithe.ly

Best for: Giving plus church management

Check out Tithe.ly
Starting price$19 per month
Free planYes

Tithe.ly brings online giving, church management and engagement tools into one platform aimed at churches of every size. Churches that treat digital giving as a priority and want member management and communication alongside it are the clearest fit. It can work for congregations that prefer a single vendor for donations and day-to-day administration.

Since giving is central to the product, churches looking mainly for service planning or relationship-centered records may prefer a different emphasis. Review how each module matches your workflow before committing, and compare with Breeze ChMS if simplicity matters most.

What we like
  • Online giving at the core
  • Management and engagement tools together
  • Designed for churches of every size
Watch out for
  • Giving-first focus may not suit all
  • Feature depth varies by area
04Pushpay logo

Pushpay

Best for: Engagement, giving and streaming

Check out Pushpay
Starting priceSee website
Free planFree trial

Pushpay describes itself as a church engagement platform covering giving, custom apps, analytics and live streaming. It fits churches that want to combine digital generosity with communication and media in a single vendor relationship, particularly congregations investing in online reach and app-based engagement with their community.

Its strengths lean toward engagement and giving rather than core membership administration, so churches seeking a records-first system may need to pair it or look elsewhere. Smaller congregations with simple needs may find a lighter option such as Breeze ChMS sufficient.

What we like
  • Giving and engagement in one platform
  • Custom apps and live streaming
  • Analytics for church leaders
Watch out for
  • Aimed at larger, engagement-focused churches
  • Less emphasis on records administration
05Rock RMS logo

Rock RMS

Best for: Relationship-centered, extensible management

Check out Rock RMS
Starting price$4.45 per average weekend attendee
Free planSee website

Rock RMS is a church management system centered on relationships, serving churches, parishes and organizations. It presents itself as a proven innovation platform with active community support, which appeals to teams that want to shape the system around their own processes rather than accept a fixed workflow. Churches with some technical capacity often gravitate to this model.

That flexibility can mean more configuration and maintenance than a hosted, simplicity-first tool. If your team has limited technical time, Breeze ChMS or Planning Center may deliver faster day-to-day results, while ShelbyNext suits finance-heavy requirements.

What we like
  • Centered on relationships
  • Positioned as an innovation platform
  • Active community support
Watch out for
  • Can require technical comfort
  • Extensibility adds setup effort
06ShelbyNext logo

ShelbyNext

Best for: Membership and financial tools

Check out ShelbyNext
Starting priceSee website
Free planSee website

ShelbyNext comes from Shelby Systems, a church management software company serving churches and non-profits with membership and financial tools. It fits congregations and organizations that put record keeping and financial administration at the center of their software decision, including non-profit settings where donor and member tracking matter alongside church operations.

Compared with engagement-oriented platforms such as Pushpay or Tithe.ly, its emphasis is administration rather than digital giving campaigns or apps. Churches wanting modern engagement features may need complementary tools, so weigh your priorities before choosing.

What we like
  • Membership and financial focus
  • Also serves non-profits
  • Established church software company
Watch out for
  • Narrower engagement feature set
  • Interface may feel traditional

How the list was put together

ToolNimba compared documented features, vendor homepage descriptions and stated limits for each option in this list. We did not test the software directly, and details can change, so confirm current capabilities on each vendor site before deciding. The ordering reflects editorial judgment about common church needs and is not a ranking or endorsement.

What to confirm before you sign up

  • Check which modules you need: records, giving, planning or engagement
  • Ask how data migration from your current system is handled
  • Confirm support channels and response expectations
  • Review reporting and financial tools against your bookkeeping
  • Test the workflow with the volunteers who will use it

Sources

Official websites of the products reviewed above. Features and prices were checked against these sites when the guide was written, and they can change, so confirm on the vendor site before you buy.

  1. https://www.planningcenter.com
  2. https://www.breezechms.com
  3. https://tithe.ly
  4. https://pushpay.com
  5. https://www.rockrms.com
  6. https://www.shelbynext.com

Frequently asked questions

Which ChurchTrac alternative is best for a small church?

Breeze ChMS is often a practical fit for small churches because it emphasizes ease of use for data, events, giving and attendance. Planning Center is a strong alternative if you also need service planning and team coordination across ministries.

Do these alternatives include online giving?

Several do. Tithe.ly and Pushpay place giving at the center of their platforms, and Breeze ChMS lists online giving among its features. Planning Center focuses on ministry organization and service planning, so check its giving options on the vendor site.

What should I compare before switching church software?

Focus on the modules you actually use, how records and donations transfer, and how much training volunteers will need. Also confirm support options and reporting needs, since administrative tools such as ShelbyNext differ from engagement platforms such as Pushpay.

Is Rock RMS harder to set up than other options?

Rock RMS presents itself as an extensible, relationship-centered platform with community support, which can mean more configuration work. Churches without technical staff may find Breeze ChMS or Planning Center quicker to adopt, depending on their needs.

Keep reading