ToolNimba
⭐ Comparisons

Givelify Alternatives: 6 Church Giving Tools for 2026

By ToolNimba Editorial Team November 20, 2026 6 min read

We did not test these tools hands-on. Picks are based on vendor documentation and public information. Read our editorial policy and disclosure.

Givelify Alternatives
  1. Top pick
    Tithe.ly logoTithe.ly

    Churches wanting giving plus management

    Starting price$19 per month
    Check out Tithe.lyRead our review
  2. Runner-up
    Pushpay logoPushpay

    Engagement-focused churches with digital ambitions

    Starting priceSee website
    Check out PushpayRead our review
  3. Also great
    Vanco logoVanco

    Simple payment processing and giving app

    Starting price$54 per month
    Check out VancoRead our review

How we researched this

We compared official pricing and feature pages, app store listings, privacy policies and public user reviews. Prices change, so check the provider's site before you pay.

Direct answer

Tithe.ly is the first pick for churches that want giving and management in one platform. Pushpay suits congregations focused on engagement and custom apps, while Donorbox fits nonprofits that mainly need donation forms. This guide compares six Givelify alternatives.

Key takeaways

  • Tithe.ly combines online giving, church management and engagement tools for churches of every size.
  • Pushpay centers on church engagement, with giving, custom apps, analytics and live streaming.
  • Vanco offers simple online payment processing and a giving app for flexible donations.
  • Bloomerang pairs fundraising tools with donor and volunteer CRM for nonprofits.

Quick comparison

NameBest forStarting priceFree plan
Tithe.lyChurches wanting giving plus management$19 per monthYesVisit
PushpayEngagement-focused churches with digital ambitionsSee websiteFree trialVisit
VancoSimple payment processing and giving app$54 per monthYesVisit
DonorboxNonprofits needing straightforward donation forms$50 per monthYesVisit
BloomerangNonprofits combining fundraising and donor CRMSee websiteSee websiteVisit
Neon CRMUnified nonprofit operations and events$99 per monthSee websiteVisit

Church and nonprofit giving platforms, one by one

Choosing a giving platform means weighing how well it handles donations, donor records and day-to-day operations. ToolNimba compared six documented alternatives to help you narrow the field.

01Tithe.ly logo

Tithe.ly

Best for: Churches wanting giving plus management

Check out Tithe.ly
Starting price$19 per month
Free planYes

Tithe.ly presents itself as a single platform for online giving, church management and engagement, aimed at churches of every size. That combination suits congregations that would rather run donations, member records and communication from one place instead of stitching separate tools together. It is a natural first stop for churches leaving a giving-only app and wanting more operational depth.

Because the platform spans giving, management and engagement, smaller congregations may find more capability than they need, and the church focus may not fit secular nonprofits. If your priority is a simple donation page rather than church operations, a leaner option such as Donorbox may be easier to adopt.

What we like
  • Online giving and church management in one platform
  • Engagement tools included
  • Built for churches of every size
Watch out for
  • Feature set may feel broad for giving-only needs
  • Church-specific focus may not suit other nonprofits
02Pushpay logo

Pushpay

Best for: Engagement-focused churches with digital ambitions

Check out Pushpay
Starting priceSee website
Free planFree trial

Pushpay describes itself as a church engagement platform that brings together giving, custom apps, analytics and live streaming. That scope fits congregations that want to reach members through branded digital tools and understand giving patterns through analytics, rather than just collecting donations. It is a reasonable candidate for churches investing in a broader digital presence.

The engagement emphasis can be more than a small church needs if the goal is simply to accept gifts online. Churches seeking straightforward payment processing with a giving app may prefer Vanco, while those wanting management and giving together might look at Tithe.ly.

What we like
  • Giving alongside custom apps
  • Analytics and live streaming included
  • Positioned as a church engagement platform
Watch out for
  • Engagement focus may exceed basic giving needs
  • Church-specific orientation
03Vanco logo

Vanco

Best for: Simple payment processing and giving app

Check out Vanco
Starting price$54 per month
Free planYes

Vanco focuses on online payment and donation processing, with a giving app that lets people give when and where they want. That makes it a fit for organizations that mainly need reliable processing and a convenient giving channel, without a large engagement suite attached. Churches and nonprofits wanting a practical donations backbone should keep it on the shortlist.

Vanco's processing-centered approach means congregations needing management, engagement or analytics may have to pair it with other software. If you want giving and church operations under one roof, Tithe.ly or Pushpay may be the better direction.

What we like
  • Online payment and donation processing
  • Giving app for flexible donations
  • Straightforward processing focus
Watch out for
  • Less emphasis on broader church management
  • May need other tools for engagement
04Donorbox logo

Donorbox

Best for: Nonprofits needing straightforward donation forms

Check out Donorbox
Starting price$50 per month
Free planYes

Donorbox is widely known as an online donation platform that helps nonprofits collect gifts through customizable forms and fundraising pages. It suits organizations that want to get donation collection running without adopting a full church management system. Smaller nonprofits and campaigns often start here because the focus stays on the giving experience itself.

Donorbox centers on donations, so churches wanting member management or engagement features may need additional software. Nonprofits that want donor records and fundraising in one place might compare Bloomerang or Neon CRM instead.

What we like
  • Donation-focused toolset
  • Well known among nonprofits for online fundraising
  • Useful for campaigns and general giving
Watch out for
  • Less oriented to church management
  • May need separate tools for donor CRM
05Bloomerang logo

Bloomerang

Best for: Nonprofits combining fundraising and donor CRM

Check out Bloomerang
Starting priceSee website
Free planSee website

Bloomerang positions its nonprofit software around fundraising, CRM and volunteer management, helping organizations acquire and manage donors and volunteers. That combination fits nonprofits that want giving history and relationship data to live together, rather than treating donations as a standalone transaction. It is a sensible choice when donor retention and stewardship are central goals.

Bloomerang is built around nonprofit CRM and fundraising, so churches looking specifically for worship-oriented giving tools may find the fit imperfect. If your main need is a simple giving app, Vanco or Donorbox may be lighter options.

What we like
  • Fundraising tools with donor CRM
  • Volunteer management included
  • Aimed at deepening donor connections
Watch out for
  • Nonprofit CRM focus rather than church giving
  • Broader suite may be more than giving-only users need
06Neon CRM logo

Neon CRM

Best for: Unified nonprofit operations and events

Check out Neon CRM
Starting price$99 per month
Free planSee website

Neon CRM, part of Neon One, combines donor management, fundraising, memberships, events and ticketing into one nonprofit platform. It fits organizations that run several programs and want registrations, memberships and donations tracked in a unified system. Nonprofits outgrowing separate donation and event tools should consider it.

The unified scope means more setup and process decisions than a donation-only tool, and it is not tailored to churches. If you only need online giving forms, Donorbox may be quicker, while churches may prefer Tithe.ly or Pushpay.

What we like
  • Donor management and fundraising together
  • Memberships, events and ticketing included
  • Single platform for nonprofit operations
Watch out for
  • Broad scope may require setup effort
  • Not church-specific

How the list was put together

ToolNimba compared documented features, vendor homepage descriptions and stated limits for each platform, keeping the list to the six tools provided. Details such as current capabilities and supported payment methods should be confirmed on each vendor site before deciding. The ordering reflects editorial judgment about common giving needs, not a formal ranking, and no hands-on testing was performed.

What to confirm before you sign up

  • Check which payment methods and currencies the platform supports
  • Confirm how donor data can be exported or integrated with other systems
  • Review whether church management or nonprofit CRM features are included
  • Ask how recurring giving and event or membership payments are handled
  • Verify support options and setup requirements on the vendor site

Sources

Official websites of the products reviewed above. Features and prices were checked against these sites when the guide was written, and they can change, so confirm on the vendor site before you buy.

  1. https://tithe.ly
  2. https://pushpay.com
  3. https://www.vancopayments.com
  4. https://donorbox.org
  5. https://bloomerang.co
  6. https://neonone.com

Frequently asked questions

What should churches look for in a Givelify alternative?

Start with whether you need giving only or giving plus management and engagement. Tithe.ly and Pushpay combine giving with broader church tools, while Vanco focuses on payment processing and a giving app. Match the feature scope to how your church actually operates.

Which alternatives suit nonprofits rather than churches?

Donorbox, Bloomerang and Neon CRM are oriented toward nonprofits. Donorbox emphasizes donation collection, Bloomerang pairs fundraising with donor CRM and volunteers, and Neon CRM unifies donors, fundraising, memberships and events. Churches may instead prefer Tithe.ly, Pushpay or Vanco.

Can I run events and memberships alongside donations?

Some platforms cover more than giving. Neon CRM includes memberships, events and ticketing in one system, and Bloomerang adds volunteer management to fundraising. Confirm on each vendor site how these modules connect to donation records before committing.

How do I compare these platforms fairly?

List your must-haves, such as recurring gifts, donor records, app-based giving or event payments, then check each vendor's documented features against that list. Confirm current capabilities directly with the vendor, since product details change over time.

Keep reading