Planning Center Alternatives: 6 Church Tools Compared 2026
By ToolNimba Editorial Team November 20, 2026 6 min read
We did not test these tools hands-on. Picks are based on vendor documentation and public information. Read our editorial policy and disclosure.
- Top pick
Breeze ChMSChurches wanting simple, easy management
Starting price$72 per monthCheck out Breeze ChMSRead our review - Runner-up
ChurchTracSmall and large churches wanting affordability
Starting price$29 per monthCheck out ChurchTracRead our review - Also great
Tithe.lyGiving and engagement in one platform
Starting price$19 per monthCheck out Tithe.lyRead our review
How we researched this
We compared official pricing and feature pages, app store listings, privacy policies and public user reviews. Prices change, so check the provider's site before you pay.
Direct answer
Breeze ChMS is the first pick for churches that want simple church management, while ChurchTrac suits smaller congregations and Tithe.ly fits giving and engagement needs. Six Planning Center alternatives are compared here on documented features and stated limits.
Key takeaways
- Breeze ChMS emphasizes ease of use for organizing people data, events, giving and attendance.
- ChurchTrac combines giving, accounting and membership tools in one user-friendly package.
- Tithe.ly brings online giving, church management and engagement together for churches of every size.
- Elvanto includes full worship planning alongside services, child check-in and volunteer rosters.
Quick comparison
| Name | Best for | Starting price | Free plan | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Churches wanting simple, easy management | $72 per month | Free trial | Visit | |
| Small and large churches wanting affordability | $29 per month | Free trial | Visit | |
| Giving and engagement in one platform | $19 per month | Yes | Visit | |
| Relationship-centered church management | $4.45 per average weekend attendee | See website | Visit | |
| Worship planning plus church management | See website | See website | Visit | |
| Membership and financial tools for churches | See website | See website | Visit |
Planning Center Alternatives Compared, one by one
Choosing church software often starts with Planning Center, but several other platforms cover similar ground in different ways. ToolNimba compared documented features and vendor descriptions to help you weigh the alternatives.
Breeze ChMS is church management software built around simplicity. Its homepage presents it as an easy-to-use tool for organizing member data, managing events, offering online giving and tracking attendance. That combination fits smaller congregations or teams that want one clear system without a steep learning curve, and it works well for churches moving away from spreadsheets or disconnected tools.
Because Breeze leans toward simplicity, churches with complex multi-site structures or heavy customization needs may find it limiting. If you need deeper worship planning or advanced accounting, compare ChurchTrac or Elvanto instead. Breeze is best treated as a practical starting point for straightforward church administration.
- Positions itself as easy to use
- Covers data, events, giving and attendance
- Straightforward church management focus
- Limited depth for complex workflows
- Fewer advanced customization options
ChurchTrac describes itself as user-friendly and affordable church software. Its homepage lists online giving, accounting, membership, child check-in, visitors, small groups, events, volunteers and attendance. That breadth makes it a strong candidate for churches that want financial tools and people management in one place, and it is positioned to serve both small and large congregations.
The wide feature set can mean more setup work than a simpler tool requires. Churches that mainly need basic member records and giving may prefer Breeze ChMS. Consider ChurchTrac when accounting and volunteer coordination are central to how your church operates.
- User-friendly interface emphasis
- Covers giving, accounting and membership
- Includes check-in, groups and attendance
- Broad feature set may feel busy
- Accounting focus may not suit every church
Tithe.ly presents online giving, church management and engagement tools as one platform for churches of every size. Its homepage frames the product around the combination of generosity and connection, which suits congregations that want giving and communication handled together rather than through separate systems.
Churches with complex worship planning or deep accounting requirements may need additional tools alongside Tithe.ly. If your priority is core member records and events, Breeze ChMS or ChurchTrac may be simpler. Pick Tithe.ly when giving and engagement are the main drivers.
- Combines giving with management
- Engagement tools included
- Suited to churches of every size
- Giving-first focus may not fit all needs
- Feature depth varies by module
Rock RMS is a church management system centered on relationships, described on its homepage as a proven innovation platform with active community support. It is used by churches, parishes and organizations, and it tends to appeal to teams that value flexibility and a model built around connecting people rather than only storing records.
That flexibility can come with more configuration effort than plug-and-play tools demand. Churches without technical support may find simpler options easier to adopt. Choose Rock RMS when relational data and extensibility matter more than a minimal setup.
- Relationship-centered design
- Active community support
- Positioned as an innovation platform
- May require technical comfort
- Less emphasis on simplicity
Elvanto offers all-inclusive church management software that includes full worship planning. Its homepage highlights managing services, child check-in and rostering volunteers with ease. That makes it a natural fit for churches where service planning and volunteer scheduling are weekly priorities and where leaders want those tasks connected to member records.
Churches that do not run detailed service planning may not use the full scope. If you mainly need giving and basic membership, Tithe.ly or Breeze ChMS could be leaner. Elvanto is worth a look when worship planning sits at the center of your operations.
- All-inclusive church management
- Full worship planning included
- Child check-in and volunteer rosters
- Planning focus may not fit every church
- Broad scope needs setup time
Shelby Systems is a church management software company that serves churches and non-profits with membership and financial tools. Its homepage positions the product around administrative record keeping and finances, which fits congregations that prioritize robust back-office handling and want a vendor focused on those core functions.
Because Shelby emphasizes membership and financial administration, churches seeking lightweight event or engagement tools may need to look elsewhere. Compare Tithe.ly for giving and engagement or Breeze ChMS for simplicity. Shelby suits teams with dedicated administrative staff.
- Membership and financial focus
- Serves churches and non-profits
- Established church software category
- Less emphasis on modern simplicity
- May suit administrative teams more than volunteers
How the list was put together
ToolNimba compared documented features, vendor homepage descriptions and stated limits for each tool in this list. Details can change, so confirm current capabilities on each vendor site before deciding. The ordering is editorial and reflects how clearly each option matches common church needs, not a scored ranking.
What to confirm before you sign up
- Check which modules you need, such as giving, accounting, check-in or worship planning
- Ask how data migration from Planning Center would work
- Confirm volunteer and staff permissions match your team structure
- Review support channels and onboarding help offered by the vendor
- Verify that reporting covers the financial and attendance views you rely on
Sources
Official websites of the products reviewed above. Features and prices were checked against these sites when the guide was written, and they can change, so confirm on the vendor site before you buy.
Frequently asked questions
What is the easiest Planning Center alternative to start with?
Breeze ChMS markets itself around ease of use and covers data, events, giving and attendance. Churches wanting a simple starting point often look there first. Larger needs may call for ChurchTrac or Elvanto.
Which alternative is best for online giving?
Tithe.ly combines online giving with church management and engagement tools. ChurchTrac also lists online giving alongside accounting. Compare both if giving is your main priority.
Do these tools include worship planning?
Elvanto explicitly includes full worship planning with service management and volunteer rosters. Other tools in this list focus more on membership, giving and administration, so check each vendor page for planning features.
How should a church choose between these alternatives?
Start by listing must-have functions such as giving, check-in or accounting, then match them to each vendor's documented features. Confirm migration, permissions and support details directly with the vendor before committing.


