Proton VPN Alternatives: 6 VPNs Compared for 2026
By ToolNimba Editorial Team November 20, 2026 6 min read
We did not test these tools hands-on. Picks are based on vendor documentation and public information. Read our editorial policy and disclosure.
- Top pick
ExpressVPNSpeed-focused privacy and streaming
Starting price$2.79 per monthCheck out ExpressVPNRead our review - Runner-up
SurfsharkBundled identity and device protection
Starting priceSee websiteCheck out SurfsharkRead our review - Also great
Mullvad VPNPrivacy-first, surveillance-resistant use
Starting priceโฌ5 per monthCheck out Mullvad VPNRead our review
How we researched this
We compared official pricing and feature pages, app store listings, privacy policies and public user reviews. Prices change, so check the provider's site before you pay.
Direct answer
ExpressVPN is the first pick for most people seeking a Proton VPN alternative, thanks to its speed focus and broad server coverage. Surfshark suits users who want identity and scam protection bundled in, while Mullvad VPN appeals to privacy purists. Six options are compared here.
Key takeaways
- ExpressVPN emphasizes speed and privacy with servers in many countries and round-the-clock support.
- Surfshark bundles identity protection, scam and phishing defense, antivirus, and a fast VPN in one package.
- Mullvad VPN centers on privacy advocacy and resistance to mass surveillance and censorship.
- Private Internet Access highlights open-source software, streaming servers, and a risk-free period to evaluate it.
Quick comparison
| Name | Best for | Starting price | Free plan | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Speed-focused privacy and streaming | $2.79 per month | No | Visit | |
| Bundled identity and device protection | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| Privacy-first, surveillance-resistant use | โฌ5 per month | No | Visit | |
| Open-source software and streaming servers | $1.89 per month | No | Visit | |
| Fast servers across many devices | $1.99 per month | Free trial | Visit | |
| VPN plus next-gen antivirus | See website | See website | Visit |
Proton VPN Alternatives Compared, one by one
Choosing a VPN often comes down to how much weight you give speed, privacy philosophy, or bundled security extras. ToolNimba compared six documented Proton VPN alternatives so you can match each one to your needs.
ExpressVPN presents itself as a speed and privacy service, pairing a global server footprint with streaming support and continuous customer assistance. It fits users who prioritize connection performance and want help available at any hour. The homepage highlights privacy protection, worldwide streaming, and a risk-free evaluation window, making it a natural first stop for anyone leaving Proton VPN.
Because its pitch leans on speed and streaming rather than an all-in-one security suite, people wanting bundled antivirus or identity monitoring may prefer Surfshark. Those who care most about privacy philosophy and open advocacy might look to Mullvad instead. Confirm current server locations and features on the vendor site before committing.
- Markets fast speeds and privacy protection
- Servers spread across many countries
- Round-the-clock customer support
- Fewer bundled security extras than some rivals
- Premium positioning may not suit budget shoppers
Surfshark positions itself as more than a VPN, folding identity protection, scam and phishing defense, and device security into one offering. It suits households and individuals who want a single service covering connection privacy plus broader digital safety. For Proton VPN users who mainly want a tunnel, the extra layers may be unnecessary, but for those seeking an all-in-one package it is a strong fit.
The breadth of features means the experience can differ across devices, so check platform support before choosing. If you want a lean, privacy-first tool with minimal extras, Mullvad VPN or Private Internet Access may align better. Verify which protections apply to your operating system on the vendor page.
- Combines VPN with scam and phishing protection
- Includes identity theft and device security features
- Markets a fast VPN connection
- Extra layers can feel like more than some users need
- Feature set varies by platform
Mullvad VPN frames itself around freeing the internet from mass surveillance and censorship, and it offers Mullvad Browser alongside the VPN. It appeals to privacy purists, journalists, and anyone who values a clear rights-focused mission over consumer frills. As a Proton VPN alternative, it shares a similar privacy-first spirit and is worth considering for that reason alone.
Users who want bundled antivirus, identity monitoring, or heavy streaming optimization may find Mullvad's focus narrower than they need. In that case Surfshark or CyberGhost VPN could be better matches. Review the vendor site for current features and supported platforms before deciding.
- Strong privacy and anti-surveillance focus
- Offers a companion privacy browser
- Clear advocacy-driven mission
- Fewer consumer extras like antivirus bundles
- Not positioned around streaming convenience

Private Internet Access
Best for: Open-source software and streaming servers
Private Internet Access markets itself on open-source software, fast speeds, and worldwide streaming servers. It fits technically minded users who value transparency in the client software and want a service oriented toward streaming. The homepage also notes a risk-free evaluation window, giving newcomers room to test it against Proton VPN.
Its technical framing may overwhelm casual users who want a simpler setup, and those seeking bundled identity protection should look at Surfshark. If a straightforward privacy mission matters more, Mullvad VPN is an alternative. Confirm current app support and features on the vendor site.
- Software described as fully open source
- Worldwide streaming servers
- Risk-free period to evaluate
- Brand messaging leans technical
- Feature emphasis differs by platform
CyberGhost VPN promotes fast servers and broad device support spanning Windows, iOS, Mac, Android, and Linux. It suits users who want a privacy tool that works across a mixed set of devices without much fuss. For Proton VPN users seeking a similarly general-purpose service, it is a reasonable candidate to compare.
If bundled scam protection or identity monitoring is important, Surfshark covers more ground. Users wanting an open-source client may prefer Private Internet Access. Check device-specific features and server availability on the vendor site before choosing.
- Emphasis on fast server performance
- Supports Windows, iOS, Mac, Android, and Linux
- Straightforward privacy positioning
- Fewer identity-protection extras than Surfshark
- Streaming performance varies by location
IPVanish combines a fast, private VPN with next-gen antivirus and advertises verified no-logs practices across a broad set of locations. It fits users who want connection protection and device security from one vendor. As a Proton VPN alternative, it stands out for those who value an integrated antivirus layer alongside the tunnel.
People who already run dedicated security software may find the antivirus bundle redundant and could prefer a leaner tool like Mullvad VPN. Those wanting identity monitoring should compare with Surfshark. Verify current locations and features on the vendor page.
- Pairs VPN with next-gen antivirus
- Wide location coverage
- Verified no-logs positioning
- Antivirus bundle may be redundant for some
- Less privacy-advocacy branding than Mullvad
How the list was put together
ToolNimba compared documented features, vendor homepage descriptions, and stated limits for each service in this list. We did not run independent speed or leak tests, so performance claims reflect vendor messaging rather than measured results. Details such as server locations, supported platforms, and bundled features can change, so confirm them on each vendor site before buying. The ordering is an editorial judgment based on how each tool is positioned for common Proton VPN use cases.
What to confirm before you sign up
- Check which platforms and devices the service officially supports
- Verify current server locations and streaming capabilities
- Review the logging and privacy policy wording directly
- Confirm whether bundled extras like antivirus or identity protection apply to you
- Check the vendor's cancellation and refund terms before subscribing
Sources
Official websites of the products reviewed above. Features and prices were checked against these sites when the guide was written, and they can change, so confirm on the vendor site before you buy.
Frequently asked questions
Which Proton VPN alternative is best for speed?
ExpressVPN leads with a speed and streaming focus, and CyberGhost VPN also emphasizes fast servers. Actual performance depends on your location and network, so test before committing.
Which alternative bundles the most security features?
Surfshark stands out by combining a VPN with scam and phishing protection, identity theft protection, and device security. IPVanish also bundles next-gen antivirus for users who want that layer.
Is there a privacy-focused alternative similar to Proton VPN?
Mullvad VPN shares a strong privacy and anti-surveillance mission and offers a companion browser. It suits users who prioritize privacy philosophy over consumer extras.
Can I try these VPNs before paying?
Several vendors, including ExpressVPN, Private Internet Access, and IPVanish, describe risk-free or money-back evaluation periods on their homepages. Review the exact terms on each vendor site, since conditions and durations vary.

