ToolNimba
⭐ Comparisons

Tithe.ly Alternatives: 6 Church Giving Tools for 2026

By ToolNimba Editorial Team November 20, 2026 7 min read

We did not test these tools hands-on. Picks are based on vendor documentation and public information. Read our editorial policy and disclosure.

Tithe.ly Alternatives
  1. Top pick
    Pushpay logoPushpay

    Churches seeking an all-in-one engagement platform

    Starting priceSee website
    Check out PushpayRead our review
  2. Runner-up
    Planning Center Giving logoPlanning Center Giving

    Churches already using Planning Center

    Starting price$5 per month
    Check out Planning Center GivingRead our review
  3. Also great
    Breeze ChMS logoBreeze ChMS

    Small churches wanting easy management

    Starting price$72 per month
    Check out Breeze ChMSRead our review

How we researched this

We compared official pricing and feature pages, app store listings, privacy policies and public user reviews. Prices change, so check the provider's site before you pay.

Direct answer

Pushpay is a strong first pick for churches wanting a full engagement platform, while Planning Center Giving suits teams already using Planning Center and ChurchTrac fits smaller churches needing affordable management. We compare six Tithe.ly alternatives to help you find the right fit.

Key takeaways

  • Pushpay combines giving, custom apps, analytics, and live streaming in one engagement platform.
  • Planning Center Giving connects online giving to an all-in-one church management system.
  • Breeze ChMS emphasizes simplicity for organizing data, events, and online giving.
  • ChurchTrac offers user-friendly church management with giving, accounting, and check-in.

Quick comparison

NameBest forStarting priceFree plan
PushpayChurches seeking an all-in-one engagement platformSee websiteFree trialVisit
Planning Center GivingChurches already using Planning Center$5 per monthYesVisit
Breeze ChMSSmall churches wanting easy management$72 per monthFree trialVisit
ChurchTracSmall churches needing affordable management$29 per monthFree trialVisit
ShelbyNextChurches and nonprofits needing financial toolsSee websiteSee websiteVisit
Ministry BrandsChurches and nonprofits seeking diverse toolsSee websiteSee websiteVisit

Tithe.ly Alternatives for Churches, one by one

Finding the right church giving platform can shape how your congregation engages with generosity. At ToolNimba, we compared six Tithe.ly alternatives based on documented features and vendor pages.

01Pushpay logo

Pushpay

Best for: Churches seeking an all-in-one engagement platform

Check out Pushpay
Starting priceSee website
Free planFree trial

Pushpay is a church engagement platform that brings together giving, custom apps, analytics, and live streaming. It is built for churches that want a unified digital experience for their congregation, from donations to media. The platform suits congregations looking to deepen engagement through multiple digital channels and may appeal to those wanting to consolidate tools.

Because Pushpay centers on broader engagement, churches seeking only a simple giving tool might find it complex. Its feature set may require more setup and administration. If your needs are limited to basic online giving, a simpler option like Planning Center Giving or ChurchTrac could be a better fit.

What we like
  • Combines giving with custom apps and live streaming
  • Provides analytics for engagement tracking
  • Designed for church-wide digital engagement
Watch out for
  • May be more than small churches need
  • Focus on engagement rather than basic giving
02Planning Center Giving logo

Planning Center Giving

Best for: Churches already using Planning Center

Check out Planning Center Giving
Starting price$5 per month
Free planYes

Planning Center Giving is an online giving tool that connects to the broader Planning Center church management system. It focuses on making giving easy for congregants while providing administrators with custom reports and fee management. Churches already using Planning Center products will find it a natural extension for donations, and it works well for teams that value integrated data.

If you are not using Planning Center for other church management tasks, the giving tool may not stand out as much on its own. It is designed to complement the suite, so standalone users might miss some context. Consider it if you are already in the Planning Center ecosystem; otherwise, explore alternatives with broader standalone features.

What we like
  • Integrates with an all-in-one church management system
  • Offers custom reporting for giving insights
  • Aims to save on processing fees
Watch out for
  • Best value within the Planning Center ecosystem
  • Limited standalone features outside giving
03Breeze ChMS logo

Breeze ChMS

Best for: Small churches wanting easy management

Check out Breeze ChMS
Starting price$72 per month
Free planFree trial

Breeze ChMS is a church management software known for its ease of use. It helps churches organize member data, manage events, offer online giving, and track attendance. The platform is designed to be intuitive, making it a good fit for small to mid-sized churches that need a straightforward system without a steep learning curve. It emphasizes simplicity over extensive customization.

Churches with complex workflows or large congregations might find Breeze lacks the depth of more robust systems. Its feature set is focused on core management tasks, so advanced reporting or specialized giving options may be limited. If you need a system that scales with significant growth or requires extensive customization, consider other options like Pushpay or ShelbyNext.

What we like
  • Simple interface for organizing church data
  • Includes online giving and event management
  • Tracks attendance with ease
Watch out for
  • May lack advanced features for large churches
  • Limited customization options
04ChurchTrac logo

ChurchTrac

Best for: Small churches needing affordable management

Check out ChurchTrac
Starting price$29 per month
Free planFree trial

ChurchTrac is a church management software designed to be user-friendly and accessible for churches of various sizes, with a focus on small to mid-sized congregations. It covers online giving, accounting, membership tracking, child check-in, visitor follow-up, small groups, events, volunteers, and attendance. The platform aims to provide a comprehensive set of tools without overwhelming users, making it a practical choice for churches seeking an all-in-one solution.

While ChurchTrac offers many features, very large churches with complex needs might outgrow it. The depth of customization and advanced reporting may be less than enterprise-level systems. If your church requires highly specialized workflows or extensive integration options, you might need to look at more advanced platforms.

What we like
  • User-friendly interface for church administration
  • Includes giving, accounting, and child check-in
  • Tracks members, visitors, and small groups
Watch out for
  • May not suit very large churches
  • Some features feel basic compared to enterprise tools
05ShelbyNext logo

ShelbyNext

Best for: Churches and nonprofits needing financial tools

Check out ShelbyNext
Starting priceSee website
Free planSee website

ShelbyNext is a church management software from Shelby Systems that serves churches and nonprofits with membership and financial tools. It is built for organizations that need robust accounting and member management, offering a structured approach to administration. The platform is suitable for churches and nonprofits that prioritize financial accuracy and detailed record-keeping over flashy engagement features.

Because ShelbyNext focuses on financial and membership management, it may not offer the same level of digital engagement tools as some alternatives. Smaller churches might find it more complex than necessary. If you need a system that emphasizes modern giving experiences and engagement, consider other options like Pushpay or Planning Center Giving.

What we like
  • Focus on membership and financial management
  • Serves both churches and nonprofits
  • Provides robust financial tracking
Watch out for
  • May be complex for small churches
  • Less emphasis on modern engagement features
06Ministry Brands logo

Ministry Brands

Best for: Churches and nonprofits seeking diverse tools

Check out Ministry Brands
Starting priceSee website
Free planSee website

Ministry Brands provides church management software and nonprofit tools, including giving, accounting, and background checks. It is designed to help organizations simplify operations and grow, serving a wide range of churches and nonprofits. The platform brings together various tools under one brand, making it a fit for organizations that want a single vendor for multiple administrative needs.

With a broad portfolio, Ministry Brands may require churches to integrate multiple products, which can add complexity. The range of options might be more than a small church needs. If you prefer a single, focused giving tool, you might find other alternatives more straightforward.

What we like
  • Offers church management, giving, and background checks
  • Serves both churches and nonprofits
  • Aims to simplify operations
Watch out for
  • Product lineup can be overwhelming to navigate
  • May require integration across multiple tools

How the list was put together

ToolNimba compared documented features, vendor pages, and stated limits for each tool. We focused on giving capabilities, church management features, and target audience as described on official sites. Details can change, so confirm specifics on vendor websites. Our ranking is editorial and based on publicly available information, not on hands-on testing.

What to confirm before you sign up

  • Check which giving features are included and how they integrate with your website.
  • Verify the level of church management support you need, such as member tracking or event planning.
  • Confirm whether the tool offers the reporting and accounting capabilities your team requires.
  • Review integration options with other software you use, like accounting or communication tools.
  • Ensure the platform's complexity matches your church size and administrative capacity.

Sources

Official websites of the products reviewed above. Features and prices were checked against these sites when the guide was written, and they can change, so confirm on the vendor site before you buy.

  1. https://pushpay.com
  2. https://www.planningcenter.com/giving
  3. https://www.breezechms.com
  4. https://www.churchtrac.com
  5. https://www.shelbynext.com
  6. https://www.ministrybrands.com

Frequently asked questions

What should I look for in a Tithe.ly alternative?

Consider your church's size, the giving features you need, and whether you want integrated church management. Look for tools that match your administrative capacity and offer the reporting and engagement options your congregation expects.

Are these alternatives suitable for small churches?

Yes, options like Breeze ChMS and ChurchTrac are designed with simplicity in mind and can work well for small churches. Larger platforms like Pushpay may offer more features but could be more than needed.

Can I use these tools for both giving and church management?

Several alternatives, such as Planning Center Giving, Breeze ChMS, and ChurchTrac, combine online giving with church management features. Pushpay focuses more on engagement, while ShelbyNext and Ministry Brands offer broader administrative tools.

How do I switch from Tithe.ly to another platform?

Start by exporting your data from Tithe.ly if possible, then review the import and setup processes for your chosen alternative. Many platforms offer migration support, so check with the vendor for guidance on transitioning giving records and member data.

Keep reading