Planning Center Giving Alternatives in 2026
By ToolNimba Editorial Team November 20, 2026 6 min read
We did not test these tools hands-on. Picks are based on vendor documentation and public information. Read our editorial policy and disclosure.
- Top pick
Tithe.lyAll-in-one giving and church management
Starting price$19 per monthCheck out Tithe.lyRead our review - Runner-up
PushpayChurches wanting a full engagement platform
Starting priceSee websiteCheck out PushpayRead our review - Also great
VancoSimple payment processing and giving app
Starting price$54 per monthCheck out VancoRead our review
How we researched this
We compared official pricing and feature pages, app store listings, privacy policies and public user reviews. Prices change, so check the provider's site before you pay.
Direct answer
Tithe.ly is a strong first pick for most churches because giving, management and engagement sit in one platform. Pushpay suits churches that want a broader engagement platform, while ChurchTrac fits smaller congregations watching their budget. Six alternatives are compared here.
Key takeaways
- Tithe.ly combines online giving with church management and engagement tools in one platform.
- Pushpay positions itself as a church engagement platform covering giving, custom apps, analytics and live streaming.
- Vanco focuses on payment processing and a giving app that works when and where donors want.
- Breeze ChMS and ChurchTrac fold online giving into broader church management, while Donorbox is a general donation platform.
Quick comparison
| Name | Best for | Starting price | Free plan | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All-in-one giving and church management | $19 per month | Yes | Visit | |
| Churches wanting a full engagement platform | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| Simple payment processing and giving app | $54 per month | Yes | Visit | |
| Easy church management with built-in giving | $72 per month | Free trial | Visit | |
| Budget-minded churches wanting broad features | $29 per month | Free trial | Visit | |
| General donation platform beyond churches | $50 per month | Yes | Visit |
Planning Center Giving Alternatives, one by one
Churches often look beyond their current giving provider as needs change, and the options differ widely in scope. ToolNimba compared six verified tools on documented features and stated limits to help you shortlist.
Tithe.ly presents online giving, church management and engagement tools as one platform for churches of every size. That combination fits congregations that want donors, member records and communication handled in a single place instead of stitching together separate services. Smaller churches can start with giving and add management features as they grow.
Because the platform spans several areas, teams may need time to configure and train on each module. A church that only wants a simple donation page and already has management software may prefer a narrower option such as Vanco or Donorbox.
- Online giving plus management tools
- Engagement features in the same platform
- Markets itself for churches of every size
- Broad feature set can take time to learn
- May be more than a giving-only church needs
Pushpay describes itself as a church engagement platform that brings giving, custom apps, analytics and live streaming together. It suits congregations that want digital giving connected to how they communicate and stream services, rather than a standalone donation form. Larger churches with several digital touchpoints are the natural audience.
The breadth of the platform can be more than a small church needs, and evaluating it typically means walking through a demo with the vendor. A congregation focused mainly on straightforward giving may find Tithe.ly or Vanco a simpler fit.
- Giving, custom apps and analytics together
- Live streaming included in the platform
- Built around church engagement
- Platform scope may exceed basic giving needs
- Demo-based sales process to evaluate
Vanco centers on online payment and donation processing, with a giving app that lets people contribute when and where they choose. It fits churches that already have management and engagement tools in place and mainly need reliable payment handling and an easy donor experience. Organizations beyond churches can use the same processing services.
Vanco is not positioned as a full church management suite, so congregations wanting member records, check-in and groups in one system should look at Breeze or ChurchTrac. It works best as a focused giving and payments layer alongside other tools.
- Online payment processing focus
- Giving app for donors
- Straightforward giving experience
- Narrower scope than full management suites
- Church management features are limited
Breeze ChMS markets itself as easy-to-use church management software that helps organize data, manage events, offer online giving and track attendance. It suits small and mid-sized churches that want giving handled inside the same system where they keep people and event records, with a learning curve most volunteers can handle.
Breeze emphasizes simplicity, so very large churches with complex workflows may outgrow it. If giving is the only need and management is already covered elsewhere, a dedicated processor such as Vanco may be a better match.
- Simple, easy-to-use interface
- Online giving inside church management
- Events and attendance tracking
- Less depth for large, complex churches
- Giving is one part of a broader tool
ChurchTrac describes itself as user-friendly and affordable church software covering online giving, accounting, membership, child check-in, visitors, small groups, events, volunteers and attendance. It fits churches that want many administrative functions under one roof without assembling several separate services, and it markets itself to both small and large congregations.
The number of modules means initial setup and training take effort, and a church that only needs a donation page may find it heavy. Congregations wanting the simplest possible management experience often compare Breeze instead.
- Giving, accounting and membership together
- Child check-in and group tools
- Markets itself as user-friendly and affordable
- Wide feature set needs setup time
- Interface depth may overwhelm very small teams
Donorbox is a donation platform used by nonprofits and other organizations to collect contributions online. Churches that want a straightforward giving form and do not need member records, check-in or group tools in the same system can use it as a focused option alongside separate church management software.
Because it is not designed around church workflows, features such as attendance, small groups and child check-in are not part of the offering. Churches wanting giving and management together should weigh Tithe.ly, Breeze or ChurchTrac first.
- Donation-focused platform
- Works for many nonprofit types
- Simple giving forms
- Not built specifically for church workflows
- Church management features are limited
How the list was put together
ToolNimba compared these six tools using documented features, vendor homepage descriptions and stated limits, keeping the same order as the verified list. We did not test the products directly, and details can change as vendors update their offerings. Confirm current features and terms on each vendor site before deciding. The ordering reflects editorial judgment about fit for common church giving needs, not a scored ranking.
What to confirm before you sign up
- Check which giving methods and payment types the tool supports for your congregation.
- Confirm how online giving connects with member records, events and attendance if you need management features.
- Ask how donors receive receipts and how funds and designations are tracked.
- Review data migration and setup support if you are moving from Planning Center Giving.
- Verify reporting, exports and accounting integration needs with your finance team.
Sources
Official websites of the products reviewed above. Features and prices were checked against these sites when the guide was written, and they can change, so confirm on the vendor site before you buy.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main difference between these alternatives?
Some tools, such as Tithe.ly, Pushpay, Breeze and ChurchTrac, combine giving with church management or engagement features. Others, like Vanco and Donorbox, focus mainly on payment processing and donations, which suits churches that already have management software.
Which alternative works best for a small church?
Breeze ChMS and ChurchTrac both emphasize ease of use and broad features for smaller congregations, while Tithe.ly offers a single platform that can grow with the church. A small church that only needs a donation page may prefer a focused option like Vanco or Donorbox.
Can I keep church management and giving in one system?
Yes. Tithe.ly, Pushpay, Breeze ChMS and ChurchTrac all present giving alongside management or engagement tools. Keeping both in one system reduces duplicate data entry, but it also means evaluating the whole platform rather than just the giving form.
What should I check before switching giving providers?
Confirm supported payment methods, how donor records and receipts are handled, and what migration support the vendor offers. Also review reporting and accounting exports with your finance team so the new tool fits existing bookkeeping.


